All-Americans
 Misty Allison |
 Kyle Baker |
 Nicole Bush |
 Anthony Hamm |
 Michelle Carson |
 William Reynolds |
Men
| 2021 | Morgan Beadlescomb |
| 2020 | Morgan Beadlescomb |
| 2019 | Morgan Beadlescomb |
| 2016 | Sherod Hardt |
| 2013 | Caleb Rhynard |
| 1997 | Kyle Baker |
| 1991 | Anthony Hamm |
| Ian Smith | |
| 1990 | Anthony Hamm |
| 1989 | Anthony Hamm |
| 1988 | Anthony Hamm |
| 1976 | Herb Lindsay |
| 1974 | Herb Lindsay |
| 1970 | Ken Popejoy |
| 1968 | Ken Lenowicz |
| 1963 | Richard Sharkey |
| 1960 | Gerald Young |
| William Reynolds | |
| 1959 | Crawford Kennedy |
| William Reynolds | |
| Gerald Young | |
| 1958 | Crawford Kennedy |
| William Reynolds | |
| Robert Lake | |
| 1957 | Crawford Kennedy |
| 1956 | Henry Kennedy |
| Gaylord Denslow | |
| Selwyn Jones | |
| Ron Wheeler | |
| 1955 | Henry Kennedy |
| Gaylord Denslow | |
| Selwyn Jones | |
| Terry Block | |
| 1953 | Lyle Garbe |
| 1952 | James Kepford |
| John Walter | |
| Wayne Scott | |
| 1951 | Ronald Barr |
| Wayne Scott | |
| 1950 | Warren Druetzler |
| James Kepford | |
| Donald Makielski | |
| 1949 | William Mack |
| Donald Makielski | |
| Warren Druetzler | |
| 1948 | Warren Druetlzer |
| William Mack | |
| Jack Dianetti |
Women
| 2024 | Rachel Forsyth |
| 2023 | Katie Osika |
| 2022 | Katie Osika |
| 2021 | Jenna Magness |
| 2020 | Jenna Magness |
| Lynsie Gram | |
| India Johnson | |
| 2019 | Annie Fuller |
| Jeralyn Poe | |
| 2018Â Â | Annie Fuller |
| 2016 | Rachele Schulist |
| 2015 | Alexis Wiersma |
| 2014 | Rachele Schulist |
| Lindsay Clark | |
| Leah O'Connor | |
| Julia Otwell | |
| 2010 | Emily MacLeod |
| 2008 | Nicole Bush |
| Lisa Senakiewich | |
| 2007 | Nicole Bush |
| 2006 | Alissa McKaig |
| Michelle Rafferty | |
| 2004 | Danette Doetzel |
| 2003 | Michelle Carson |
| 2002 | Michelle Carson |
| 2000 | Ann Somerville |
| 1996 | Stephanie Dueringer |
| 1991 | Misty Allison |
| 1988 | Mary Shea |
| 1981 | Anne Pewe |
| Jill Washburn | |
| Karen Campbell-Lutzke |